Liberty is an inherently offensive lifestyle. Living in a free society guarantees that each one of us will see our most cherished principles and beliefs questioned and in some cases mocked. That psychic discomfort is the price we pay for basic civic peace. It's worth it. It's a pragmatic principle. Defend everyone else's rights, because if you don't there is no one to defend yours. -- MaxedOutMama

I don't just want gun rights... I want individual liberty, a culture of self-reliance....I want the whole bloody thing. -- Kim du Toit

The most glaring example of the cognitive dissonance on the left is the concept that human beings are inherently good, yet at the same time cannot be trusted with any kind of weapon, unless the magic fairy dust of government authority gets sprinkled upon them.-- Moshe Ben-David

The cult of the left believes that it is engaged in a great apocalyptic battle with corporations and industrialists for the ownership of the unthinking masses. Its acolytes see themselves as the individuals who have been "liberated" to think for themselves. They make choices. You however are just a member of the unthinking masses. You are not really a person, but only respond to the agendas of your corporate overlords. If you eat too much, it's because corporations make you eat. If you kill, it's because corporations encourage you to buy guns. You are not an individual. You are a social problem. -- Sultan Knish

All politics in this country now is just dress rehearsal for civil war. -- Billy Beck

Wednesday, June 15, 2005

Let the Discussion Begin!

Opening Salvo by Guest poster Alex:
Kevin- instead of taking the “Jane you ignorant slut” approach to a response, I will go point by point and refute your arguments. In many cases I think the logic just doesn’t hold, and in others it may just be a difference of opinion.
That being said, let the games begin.
You say:
“I suggest you read, very carefully, the opening paragraphs of the Declaration of Independence. It was written by Thomas Jefferson and signed by quite a number of intelligent, well-educated, propertied men who decided to stand up against tyranny and break the law in so doing. They pledged their (yes, I know it’s a cliché) “lives, fortunes, and sacred honor” in that decision. And most of them lost their lives and fortunes, and several their families. But they kept their honor. Is your argument that there is never a time to rise up against tyranny? Or is it that our government can never become tyrannical?”
Ok, aside from the implication that I haven’t read the Declaration (which is wrong), you completely muddle up what I originally said, and even what I think you are trying to say. But if we look at the first paragraphs of the Declaration we can clear up both points. I never made an argument “that there is never a time to rise up against tyranny” or “that our government can never become tyrannical”. My point was actually simple. That vigilantes- however well intentioned are not revolutionaries, and that when you start talking about throwing off the oppression of the government, it needs to be against actual tyranny- not just something you don’t happen to like.
The opening paragraphs of the Declaration are clear on this point. “Prudence, indeed, will dictate that Governments long established should not be changed for light and transient causes”. Pretty clear. It then goes on to list specific and demonstrative overreaches of the King which necessitate the formation of a new government. No representation (this is fundamental to all forms of tyranny). King’s control of the judiciary. The king’s ability to ignore passed laws. Placing the military superior to the civilian. These are major transgressions. And they are designed to keep people from ever having the power to peacefully change their own government through democracy. When, and only when, that right is taken away should the “take up arms for the struggle” idea be flouted.
However none of your previous examples were examples of anything but self defense or vigilantes. And when you support vigilantes you are, in fact supporting tyranny (via mob rule). Long way to go to make my point, but you gun guys like to wrap yourselves up in the flag and say you are preserving democracy and “keeping the government in check”. That is a total crock (my opinion) and belittles the true strength of our democracy- to change without guns through the system in place.
You say:
“All too many of the other great tragedies of history - Stalin’s atrocities, the killing fields of Cambodia, the Holocaust, to name but a few - were perpetrated by armed troops against unarmed populations. Many could well have been avoided or mitigated, had the perpetrators known their intended victims were equipped with a rifle and twenty bullets apiece, as the Militia Act required here. If a few hundred Jewish fighters in the Warsaw Ghetto could hold off the Wehrmacht for almost a month with only a handful of weapons, six million Jews armed with rifles could not so easily have been herded into cattle cars.”
Ah yes- the tired line of “if only everyone had guns, there would have been no [fill in the atrocity]”. A classic, and wholly flawed argument. It assumes that there is no final solution but armed confrontation, and that any despot attempting tyranny would be thwarted at the first armed resistance. History dictates that armed conflicts can escalate into protracted civil wars, which can be far more devastating to a society than an occupation (and eventual overthrow) of a regime. Take the civil rights struggle in this country. There is no denying how brutal, oppressive and despotic the efforts made to deny a population of their civil rights were from the 40’s to the 70’s in the south. (Yes I know the rights movement began before that, but the really dangerous times- ones in which the demand for equality was met with swift retribution began in earnest in this time) So just arm them, right, and no problems?
What you would have created there is a second civil war. An armed insurgency within our own borders, and, as is the inevitable conclusion of all civil wars, mass casualties and utter destruction. Take the number of blacks tortured, maimed and killed during this period (and it is not a insignificant number, I know) and compare that to a full fledged armed conflict between blacks and whites in the south. Yes, it is comparing a known figure with an unknown, but that is exactly the part the gun guys gloss over. Do you think the whites would have just given up? “Whoa, they are armed, this changes everything… better pack it all in and just leave them alone!” or do you think they would have hunkered down, and gone all out to wipe them out completely. And, in the end, the side with the most resources is more likely to win any conflict, so the blacks still would (probably) have lost the struggle, but at a far greater toll. The civil right struggle would have ben set back decades, and all the rights they eventually gained would still have to be earned- through non-violent means- meaning they got decimated just to do the same thing they had to do anyway. Before you say “an armed populace is a free populace” study the nature of civil wars, because that is the logical conclusion of “everybody has guns”.
You say:
“You ask, “Who(se) definition of society do we have to abide by”? Good question, and one we’re constantly answering. My personal opinion: the one defined by the Constitution. No wonder forces on both the Left and the Right are trying to “reinterpret” it to mean whatever they want it to mean. This is the crux of the entire discussion. I want to keep the power to say NO!! and make it hurt in the hands of individuals, and the Statists - both Left and Right - want to ensure that the use of violence remains strictly in the hands of Government. My way, a lot of day-to-day mayhem takes place. The other way has, historically, can lead to what Professor Rudolph J. Rummel terms “Democide”. There’s that mistake you only get to make once.”
Here we are again at the “my gun is preserving your democracy” argument. This is based on an outdated, romantic delusion of being the struggling freedom fighter single-handedly battling back the “jack booted thugs” trying to take away out liberty. At some point in history, that may have held water, but it doesn’t today. You want to know what will actually take away our freedom? It’s people (on the right and left) who tell us what we can and cannot say, or even think. Being “politically correct” on the left, or “supportive of our troops” on the right has led people to suggest some pretty large steps to tyranny. They brand anyone that doesn’t think exactly the way they do as a threat to “our way of life”, and seek to squash this minority. No debate, just my way or the highway.
The ability to consolidate media in the hands of a few (and to prevent the media from serving as the nation’s watchdog, as it should and must), the ability to allow money to influence our legislature to the degree it does, the attacking of an independent judiciary which is they very backbone of any democracy, and the attempt by those in power to change the rules and checks and balances within the system to stay in power- THESE are the actual threats to a modern democracy. And all your guns won’t do a damn thing to stop them.
You keep waiting for the army to come kicking down your door and “take away the guns”, while the hyper-real threat just unfolds before your eyes and you do nothing. Talk about taking your eyes off the ball. If the groups that spend all the resources crying about how the big bad guvment wants to take away their God-given right to own a bazooka spent half their time actually doing something about the real threats to democracy, we’d all be better off. But I guess putting your money where your mouth is seems like to much to ask. Better to just keep deluding yourself as the nation’s last line of defense, instead of actually realizing that a bunch of nitwits in cammo armed to the teeth are doing zero to protect us from the real threats. But, hey, as long as they support the 2nd amendment we’ll all be OK, right?
You say:
A bunch of arguments about ballistic fingerprinting, gun control efforts in other countries and ineffective tracking measures. (There was a lot of arguments entangled here, and I am not dismissing them by not breaking them out individually, you had very good points -it just seemed like a long recap, so I skipped reprinting them).
You made some decent points here, and I definitely need to educate myself more about the current technologies available before I can refute your considerable evidence. It will take me a while to do that, so all I can do for now is attack a simple premise.
Even if I concede that the technology currently used in attempts at “ballistic fingerprinting” (BF) today does not work effectively (which I am not ready to concede until I get a full assessment, not just the “gun guys spin”), nothing you have shown that it could not be made to work should the technology improve. (i.e. there is no fundamental hurdle that seems impossible to overcome). Star Wars (the military technology- not the once great movie series bastardized into mindless pap), as an example, contains a fatal technology flaw. EMP (the force generated during a nuclear blast) wipes out mechanical and electronic components within a very large radius. So, even if you build a prefect missile hunting satellite (which is still a ways off), the entire network can easily be wiped out by a few detonations in space. This is a fundamental technological flaw- something that no scientist has even hinted at having an idea how to overcome. BF, even in its currently flawed state, does not seem to have these “there is no way imaginable to make this work”. It just needs to improve the technology in place.
Plus, this technology has had zero assistance from the gun manufacturing industry (in fact there has been outright hostility to this approach). So it is natural to assume (at least until proven otherwise) that should the engineers that design guns and ammunition, actually become engaged in producing traceable evidence, the technology would be significantly advanced. Put simply, if the gun industry actually separated the efforts to track criminals from the efforts to control all guns, we’d get somewhere. But they don’t. They look at any sensible reform efforts as the tip of an iceberg that will annihilate the second amendment. Now if there is a reason to oppose the concept of BF, I’d like to hear it. It only affects criminals and aids in their capture (again, the concept- not necessarily the current science). If you want to argue on the practicality of the current state of technology, that’s fine. But if you want to attack the entire idea of BF, that seems wholly indefensible. Sorry I cannot be more specific in this argument about the specifics on the current state, but you presented enough compelling evidence to convince me that it is far more complicated than I originally thought, although I don’t think it is as dire as you portray it (however I can’t back that up… yet)
To recap this diatribe:
1) Yes, you can rise up against a despotic regime imposing tyranny. However, taking the law into your own hands just because you don’t like something the government is doing is being a vigilante. And the examples you gave were of just that. Bullets are not needed as long as ballots are used.
2) It’s easy to say “this would never have happened if they were armed”. Yet it ignores the effect of a protracted armed conflict, which often times would be far worse than the oppression in the first place. At a minimum it is lazy thinking that presumes that guns will stop people from committing terrible acts.
3) You gun does not prevent tyranny. Tyranny today disguises itself in the “need to protect our values” and the Orwellian doublespeak that passes as governance today. It doesn’t come in through a kicked down door by the government, it comes in through defining certain speech as acceptable, and the people who don’t speak like that as “threats”. It lures the unsuspecting in with catch phrases and litmus test that weed out the “troubling elements” and says “we want what you want so lets punish the other guys”. Until you become an “other guy”. And all the guns in the world wont stop it.
4) There are certainly valid concerns about the existing BF technology. But using that to throw out the entire concept is crazy. The question should be, “could we make traceable guns and ammunition that resist tampering?” But the gun industry won’t have it. Better to just look at the first attempt and say “see, it doesn’t work. Better can the whole thing.” All science evolves, and if there isn’t a fundamental scientific reason BF can’t work in concept, then we just have to try harder.
Despite this long winded response, I still don’t think this argument gets at the real core of someone who is in favor of some sensible controls, and a typical “from my cold dead hands” fanatic.
I’d like to challenge you to a larger debate (I don’t think these issues get at the heart of our differences). One that looks at the gun industry as a whole, where reform makes sense, typical straw men used in gun rights arguments, and a comparison of international efforts for gun control. I think only in this type of debate could we really expose some sloppy thinking (on both sides) and dispel of the classic sound bites that do nothing to advance either side’s argument.
(Edited just a little bit by siteowner for readability, and to give it a title.)

Monday, June 13, 2005

Freedom's Just Another Word for "Nothin' Left to Lose".


I ran across a quotation a few days ago that struck me pretty hard. I don't really know why. It isn't, in content, any different from many others I'm familiar with. Then this evening I read a post at No Quarters that reminded me afresh. Gunner posted the entire "Give me Liberty" speech by Patrick Henry which was certainly apropos, and I'll repost it here:
No man thinks more highly than I do of the patriotism, as well as abilities, of the very worthy gentlemen who have just addressed the House. But different men often see the same subject in different lights; and, therefore, I hope it will not be thought disrespectful to those gentlemen if, entertaining as I do opinions of a character very opposite to theirs, I shall speak forth my sentiments freely and without reserve. This is no time for ceremony. The questing before the House is one of awful moment to this country. For my own part, I consider it as nothing less than a question of freedom or slavery; and in proportion to the magnitude of the subject ought to be the freedom of the debate. It is only in this way that we can hope to arrive at truth, and fulfill the great responsibility which we hold to God and our country. Should I keep back my opinions at such a time, through fear of giving offense, I should consider myself as guilty of treason towards my country, and of an act of disloyalty toward the Majesty of Heaven, which I revere above all earthly kings.

Mr. President, it is natural to man to indulge in the illusions of hope. We are apt to shut our eyes against a painful truth, and listen to the song of that siren till she transforms us into beasts. Is this the part of wise men, engaged in a great and arduous struggle for liberty? Are we disposed to be of the number of those who, having eyes, see not, and, having ears, hear not, the things which so nearly concern their temporal salvation? For my part, whatever anguish of spirit it may cost, I am willing to know the whole truth; to know the worst, and to provide for it.

I have but one lamp by which my feet are guided, and that is the lamp of experience. I know of no way of judging of the future but by the past. And judging by the past, I wish to know what there has been in the conduct of the British ministry for the last ten years to justify those hopes with which gentlemen have been pleased to solace themselves and the House. Is it that insidious smile with which our petition has been lately received? Trust it not, sir; it will prove a snare to your feet. Suffer not yourselves to be betrayed with a kiss. Ask yourselves how this gracious reception of our petition comports with those warlike preparations which cover our waters and darken our land. Are fleets and armies necessary to a work of love and reconciliation? Have we shown ourselves so unwilling to be reconciled that force must be called in to win back our love? Let us not deceive ourselves, sir. These are the implements of war and subjugation; the last arguments to which kings resort. I ask gentlemen, sir, what means this martial array, if its purpose be not to force us to submission? Can gentlemen assign any other possible motive for it? Has Great Britain any enemy, in this quarter of the world, to call for all this accumulation of navies and armies? No, sir, she has none. They are meant for us: they can be meant for no other. They are sent over to bind and rivet upon us those chains which the British ministry have been so long forging. And what have we to oppose to them? Shall we try argument? Sir, we have been trying that for the last ten years. Have we anything new to offer upon the subject? Nothing. We have held the subject up in every light of which it is capable; but it has been all in vain. Shall we resort to entreaty and humble supplication? What terms shall we find which have not been already exhausted? Let us not, I beseech you, sir, deceive ourselves. Sir, we have done everything that could be done to avert the storm which is now coming on. We have petitioned; we have remonstrated; we have supplicated; we have prostrated ourselves before the throne, and have implored its interposition to arrest the tyrannical hands of the ministry and Parliament. Our petitions have been slighted; our remonstrances have produced additional violence and insult; our supplications have been disregarded; and we have been spurned, with contempt, from the foot of the throne! In vain, after these things, may we indulge the fond hope of peace and reconciliation. There is no longer any room for hope. If we wish to be free-- if we mean to preserve inviolate those inestimable privileges for which we have been so long contending--if we mean not basely to abandon the noble struggle in which we have been so long engaged, and which we have pledged ourselves never to abandon until the glorious object of our contest shall be obtained--we must fight! I repeat it, sir, we must fight! An appeal to arms and to the God of hosts is all that is left us!

They tell us, sir, that we are weak; unable to cope with so formidable an adversary. But when shall we be stronger? Will it be the next week, or the next year? Will it be when we are totally disarmed, and when a British guard shall be stationed in every house? Shall we gather strength by irresolution and inaction? Shall we acquire the means of effectual resistance by lying supinely on our backs and hugging the delusive phantom of hope, until our enemies shall have bound us hand and foot? Sir, we are not weak if we make a proper use of those means which the God of nature hath placed in our power. The millions of people, armed in the holy cause of liberty, and in such a country as that which we possess, are invincible by any force which our enemy can send against us. Besides, sir, we shall not fight our battles alone. There is a just God who presides over the destinies of nations, and who will raise up friends to fight our battles for us. The battle, sir, is not to the strong alone; it is to the vigilant, the active, the brave. Besides, sir, we have no election. If we were base enough to desire it, it is now too late to retire from the contest. There is no retreat but in submission and slavery! Our chains are forged! Their clanking may be heard on the plains of Boston! The war is inevitable--and let it come! I repeat it, sir, let it come.

It is in vain, sir, to extenuate the matter. Gentlemen may cry, Peace, Peace-- but there is no peace. The war is actually begun! The next gale that sweeps from the north will bring to our ears the clash of resounding arms! Our brethren are already in the field! Why stand we here idle? What is it that gentlemen wish? What would they have? Is life so dear, or peace so sweet, as to be purchased at the price of chains and slavery? Forbid it, Almighty God! I know not what course others may take; but as for me, give me liberty or give me death!
Strong words, spoken at the end of hope for any peaceful resolution.

In the post immediately below that one, Gunner discusses Claire Wolfe's much-repeated quotation:
America is at that awkward stage. It's too late to work within the system, but too early to shoot the bastards.
He quotes Claire talking about that quip:
People have started using the expression "Claire Wolfe time" and "half past Claire Wolfe" to talk about how bad our loss of freedom is becoming. I can't tell you how strange it is to have my name becoming a metaphor for the moment a shooting war begins.

--

What's scarier is that I can no longer think of any moral reason not to "shoot the bastards." I can think of many, many pragmatic reasons not to attack government thugs and their bosses. I'm still not advocating that anyone commit violence (not even against TSA screeners, federal prosecutors, or cops at checkpoints -- though I understand the impulse).

But with freedom being sucked away and absolutely no one making any effective large-scale effort to restore it (but lots of people making effective large-scale efforts to destroy it), I can easily see how the next checkpoint or the next arbitrary detention or the next demand for biometric ID will simply be The Moment for some of us. Not just for the edgy Carl Drega people, either. But for good, solid, sensible people who must make the choice either to live with themselves or live as a cowed, obedient comrade of the Stalinist state being created around them.

--

Sometimes survival of freedom's soul requires uttering a big, fat, frickin' loud, emphatic, get-out-of-my-face right this minute, no doubt about it, this planet ain't big enough for the two of us NO.

And that "NO" -- as governments understand and dread -- is best enforced at the point of a gun in the hands of a determined citizen willing and ready to use it.

Why must anyone be squeezed into making that choice in America, of all places? Nothing is more heartbreaking. Why the hell can't governments just get out of our way and let ordinary people go about their business unmolested?
I left a comment on Gunner's blog pointing to my conclusion that Claire was wrong. It's not too early, it's too late.

There's a discussion running over at AR15.com this evening about the Supreme Court's vacating the 9th Circuit's U.S. v Stewart decision and what it means. I'm sure there are discussions on many other boards about it. Here are a few example posts in reaction:
Exactly as I expected after the Raich ruling. The Feds can now legislate/regulate just about anything in your daily lives and to hell with what the states think.

Knew it was going to happen, but it still sucks.

--

Raich and McCain-Feingold basically said that the Federal government has unlimited powers, and state's rights no longer exist. The United States of the Founders is gone, and the US Constitution can be ignored at will.

--

We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. --That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed, --That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness. US Declaration of Independence.

Time to do it again.

--

The very reason for the Supreme Court was to validate rulings using the Constitution as the final arbiter.

Now all the entire legal system does is base shitty and unconstitutional law on previous shitty and unconstitutional law using the bullshit excuse of "precedent".

We're fucked.

The system was set up as a LIMITED Federal government GRANTED those powers not reserved to the States and the People. It's been totally flipped the other way. The Federal government has given themselves virtual control over EVERYTHING that is done in this country. The States are merely annoying political sub-divisions that are obstacles to get around (again through more "interpreted" laws). The ultimate tool is financial. The system has been rigged to give most of states citizen's tax monies to the Federal government and therefore if you don't comply with what the Feds want, we'll simply find one of those hundreds-of-thousands of laws we've created that say we can't give you any of YOUR money back. Too bad, so sad.

States rights were at the heart of the first Civil War. The ground work is being laid for the second one in exactly the same way.

I'm 48. I wonder if I'll see it happen before I die?

--

We are governed by tyrants and traitors. The Constitution is regarded by the government it created as a contemptible rag.

We, and our own fathers, allowed the Republic the Founding Fathers authored to be slowly digested by those who promise that intrusions are so small as to be meaningless, or shriek that transitory emergencies must be allowed to override ancient liberties.

We have a health care privacy law whose primary effect is to ensure the right of hospitals and insurers to sell your private health information. We lurch toward national ID cards; our anonymity when unoffending is not assured by the privacy right that allows us to kill unborn children and sodomize one another. Your 12 year-old daughter has a right to privacy that assures that she can undergo an invasive surgical procedure without your knowledge, but does not guarantee that she can walk down a public street without disclosing her identity to any interested minion of the law. The First Amendment protects pornography - even simulated child pronography - and flag-burning, but it does not guarantee the right to criticize a congressman in the 60 days before an election.

We begin to reap the consequences of the ill-considered forbearance that allowed Chief Justice Hughes to say "We are under a Constitution, but the Constitution is what the judges say it is," and escaped unhanged. What generations of lawyers and politicians have taken as elevated drollery or cynical realism was in fact civic blasphemy and open treason. We have for centuries said with pride that we are governed by laws rather than men; we have celebrated the rule of law. It is time we began to dig its grave. We are governed by men, by majoritarian whim, by horsetraders and whores in Congress, by judicial cowardice and caprice, by every vile, low, unworthy, ungodly, despicable artifice and trick that led to the rebellion of '76, lacking only a crown.


We draw closer and closer to the hell of totalitarianism or the hell of revolution. Wise men will contemplate their choice of poisons.

--

You know, when a computer gets bogged down with too much shit floating around in it... memory leaks, orphaned processes... you need to do a CTRL-ALT-DEL to reboot, just to get a fresh start.

The gov't needs a CTRL-ALT-DEL every so often just to get rid of the accumulated shit that's built up.

And it doesn't need to be by force... the founders should have made a mandatory maximum sunset clause for every law that was passed, and each one must be be brought up for debate individually before renewing it. Eventually you would get to the point where all our elected officials would have time to do is renew laws. They wouldn't have the time to cram anything else down our throats.

--

Yes, all that is interesting but can you tell me when the next American Idol comes on please. All this talk of government wears me out. I need to know who: is voted off the island, or makes it too the next round, or can't control their kids, or will have a house built for them they can't afford thanks to lease payments to the federal and state government.

I fear the nation left to my daughter will be no better than any other socialist hell by the time I'm off this mortal coil. Sometimes I wish it would just come to a boil so we can get on with it.... slide down the sewer or pick a fight. My heart wants to think men will not stand for it. My head tells me only a very few will risk their middle-class home, 3 cars, and big screen for any ideal such as freedom. It makes me sad.

I hate to quote a movie but one of my favorite quotes from The Patriot: "Why would I trade one tyrant three thousand miles away for three thousand tyrants one mile away. An elected legislature can trample a man's rights as surely as a king". The real tyrant is an ignorant population. They are all around you and only 1 in 50 can correctly tell you what any portion of the Constitution means or why it's important.
That last one was the most insightful, accurate post in the thread.

Just yesterday I finished re-reading Heinlein's masterpiece The Moon is a Harsh Mistress. I can't tell you how many times I've read it. I know I, personally, have worn out three copies. It's a great read, and a sobering look into the mechanics of revolution. I am constantly in awe of the men and women who carried off our American revolution and then made the government that we, their descendants, have so badly mangled. Claire Wolfe asks "Why the hell can't governments just get out of our way and let ordinary people go about their business unmolested?" Heinlein has an answer:
Must be a yearning deep in human heart to stop other people from doing as they please. Rules, laws - always for other fellow. A murky part of us, something we had before we came down out of trees, and failed to shuck when we stood up.
I'm beginning to believe that Edward O. Wilson's analysis of Marxism, "Wonderful theory. Wrong species." is applicable to self-government as well. It certainly appears to be.

So what was that quote? I found it a few days ago at American Digest. It's from a speech Alexander Solzhenitsyn gave at Harvard in 1978. It's taken out of context, but it really does stand alone:
In a state of psychological weakness, weapons become a burden for the capitulating side. To defend oneself, one must also be ready to die; there is little such readiness in a society raised in the cult of material well-being. Nothing is left, then, but concessions, attempts to gain time and betrayal.
Claire Wolfe thinks that we'll individually reach some breaking point: "I can easily see how the next checkpoint or the next arbitrary detention or the next demand for biometric ID will simply be The Moment for some of us." I made that observation myself in Pressing the "RESET" Button:
I don't think you're going to see a widespread armed uprising. What you're going to see is individuals and small groups who've simply had enough arming and striking - and probably dying in the process. If you've read John Ross's Unintended Consequences you'll get the idea, but I don't expect anything like the level of response he writes of. Not enough people are pissed off enough to do that.

Of course the media will spin it as "lone deranged gun-nuts" or "anti-government militias," but if you pay attention you'll note an increase in the numbers over time.
Read that whole piece.

Thomas Jefferson's greatest fear has come home to roost, "lethargy, the forerunner of death to the public liberty." Many, but not most of us can see what's happening. Most, but not all of us who see it simply ignore it, shoving it into the recesses of our consciences. We have too much to lose. There's still some hope. It's not our responsibility. Who's getting booted off of Survivor tonight? Can you believe that Michael was acquitted?

For more and more of us, though, I think Claire's right. A few of us are going to reach our own individual Moments and those reactions will be used as excuses to further tighten the clamps, but for the majority the "cult of material well-being" has resulted in psychological weakness. "Give me liberty or give me death" is not a phrase they can embrace.

So as for me? I'm going to stick to my own advice:
(M)y life, my fortune, and my sacred honor stand ready to be sacrificed in the defense of my rights and the rights of those I love as I understand them. I am a citizen of this nation as much or as little as it protects and defends those rights under which it was founded, not as they are (mis)understood today. I will obey those laws with which I agree, follow those laws I am unwilling to suffer the penalty for, and I will disobey those laws I find egregious. This may mean that, at some time in the future, the State may decide to "selectively enforce" itself on me to make an example. At that time and at that place I will decide how to respond, for that choice is mine and always will be. In the mean time, I will agitate for those rights, making sure those in power remember that they swore oaths to defend them whether they understood them or not. I will continue trying to educate others so that they, too, understand what it is they are losing, what they are allowing others to throw away, and so they will hopefully not choose slavery.

That's what I owe my grandchildren.
But I weep for the legacy they should be receiving.
Gonzales v Raich Draws its First Gun Law Victim.

If you haven't, read my earlier piece "Game Over, Man. Game Over." It gives decent background information on the U.S. v Stewart decision in which the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the conviction of a man for possessing a firearm after being convicted of a felony, but decided that his possession of a home-made fully-automatic weapon was not per se illegal as it did not affect interstate commerce and therefore was outside the power of the Federal government to regulate.

If you weren't aware, an individual can build himself a firearm with perfect legality. He just can't ever sell it. The Stewart decision said that individuals can build themselves fully-automatic weapons, too, even though the 1986 Firearm Owner's Protection Act carried a rider making it illegal to manufacture any new fully-automatic weapons for the general public. (Police, other government agencies, and properly licensed corporations were excepted from this ban.)

Well, that decision (unsurprisingly) was appealed to the Supreme Court. They granted certiorari on it today, vacating the decision and remanding it to the 9th Circuit. Note the instructions:
The motion of respondent for leave to proceed in forma pauperis is granted. The petition for a writ of certiorari is granted. The judgment is vacated and the case is remanded to the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit for further consideration in light of Gonzales v. Raich, 545 U.S.
I wrote a little piece on the Raich decision, and quoted Justice Thomas:
If the Federal Government can regulate growing a half-dozen cannabis plants for personal consumption (not because it is interstate commerce, but because it is inextricably bound up with interstate commerce), then Congress' Article I powers--as expanded by the Necessary and Proper Clause--have no meaningful limits. Whether Congress aims at the possession of drugs, guns, or any number of other items, it may continue to appropria[te] state police powers under the guise of "regulating commerce."

--

If Congress can regulate this under the Commerce Clause, then it can regulate virtually anything--and the Federal Government is no longer one of limited and enumerated powers.
It's pretty obvious that the Supreme Court just told the 9th Circuit, "No homemade machineguns. To hell with limited powers."

That was quicker than I expected. Good to know where we stand, I suppose.

Of course, David Hardy covers the story earlier and better than I did.

I'm So Ashamed to be American...

Lileks is at his screedy best today, fisking Time's breathless exposé of "prisoner torture" at Gitmo. It's a must-read. Excerpt:
And at one point the reader might assume that if something really bad had happened, we might have read about it by now. I know a little bit about modern journalism, and we tend to emphasis the splintery plunger up the butt over the mocking puppet show. In any case, this detail makes you almost want to weep in frustration; domestic politicians are posturing for the camera, huffing about then horrors of Gitmo, insisting that the rest of the world won’t forgive us until we close the joint down and pave it. Over what? A Punch and Judy show? If we gang-mimed the guy and had 17 men in striped shirts with white makeup pantomime falling out of a burning skyscraper, would the critics demand we not only let the guy go but pay him a per diem for his troubles? I’ve read the story twice, and I keep wondering if I missed the part where the suspected 20th hijacker spits teeth into a chamberpot rimming with own bloody urine while massaging the welts the jumper cables left on his groinal division. I mean, I take all that for granted, because our soldiers are all killbot brutes - except for the lower-class ones who got drafted against their will and can only hope Bruce Springsteen sings a monotonal account of their disaffection.
You've GOT to read the lyrics! And the rest of the piece, for that matter.

Wahabism delenda est
. And we're still using kid gloves.

UPDATE: Welcome Salon readers, especially those of you from the left side of the spectrum. I'm honored that The Daou Report saw fit to link to little old me. (Must've been the post title.) Take some time, peruse the site. And if you see anything that really irks you, drop me an email. Or leave an anonymous comment like you usually do. Be sure to read my invitation to my readers, though!

Sunday, June 12, 2005

Another Best of Me Symphony.

Edition #81 of the Symphony is up at The Owner's Manual, and yes, I have an entry this week. This week's guest-host: Pat "Barking-Mad" Buchanan, the Republican Right's version of Gov. Dean.

Only Pat isn't running the Republican Party's fundraising effort.

(Which party is the Stupid Party, and which is the Evil Party again? I'm a little gray on that.)

Myths


I found this quote in a book review, but it resonates:
While our technology influences the means by which we live, it is the myths we believe in that determine how we live.
That is an idea that I understand. Abigale Kohn subtitled her book Shooters, "Myths and Realities of America's Gun Cultures." Strewn throughout that book are illuminating paragraphs like this one:
In the 2000 movie The Patriot, South Carolina farmer/landowner Benjamin Martin (played by Mel Gibson) reluctantly rejoins the colonial militia to take on the British during the Revolutionary War. With his wily bravery and unorthodox battle strategies, Martin embodies the ideal citizen soldier, displaying the kind of courage and principle that Aemricans have always imagined marked the early militiamen. The Patriot assures viewers that abstract political principles can have significant personal impact, and that American mythic history, wars and violent conflict forge timeless links between manhood, citizenship, and patriotism. Such mythic (re)tellings continue to resonate with how Americans process their own history, as the success of such movies demonstrate at the box office.
She says that almost like it's a bad thing.

I've had long, involved discussions here at TSM on the subject of what "rights" are, and from my perspective they are our shared myths, and our unique, glorious gift to the world. (Don't write letters! Oh, hell, go ahead.)

There are three things I'd like you to take time to read. None is short, so make a hole in your schedule for them. The first is Michael Yon's latest dispatch from Iraq, The Battle for Mosul. The next is not online today, but it will be in a week. However, you should be able to find it pretty easily, since it's in today's Parade Sunday insert. The story is entitled Proud to be an American, and it's about the U.S. Navy's hospital ship Mercy and its recent tour of the tsunami-smashed Indian Ocean area. The third piece I want you to read is an AP (!) piece, Special-ed kid who won't quit hits one of life's great 3-pointers.

Read those three pieces. Reflect on the myths that we as Americans share that lead us to such behavior, both as individuals and as a whole people. And then compare that to the myths that lead people to drive car bombs into crowds of children killing them wholesale, or encourage them to use a child as a decoy, that let them murder foreign journalists and aid workers, that convince them that it is better for young girls to burn to death inside their schoolhouse than to allow them to escape the flames with their heads uncovered.

And tell me then, if you can, why I should concern myself over whether some guards in Guantanamo have shown disrespect for the Koran.

Contrary to popular belief, some cultures are superior to others, regardless of what the American Left espouses.

Honesty is Such a Lonely Word...


Color me shocked when I saw the cover of today's Arizona Daily Star:
The story is available online here. Excerpt:
They're pulled from backyard pools and bathtubs each year, tiny limp bodies, blue and not breathing.
A young life can vanish quickly under water. A survivor can endure a lifetime of disabilities. Either way, families are torn apart by an almost always preventable tragedy.
Standard summer companions in our desert climate, swimming pools can be deadlier for children than guns. A child is 100 times more likely to die in a swimming accident than in gunplay, writes Steven D. Levitt, University of Chicago economics professor and best-selling author.
Levitt analyzed child deaths from residential swimming pools and guns and found one child under 10 drowns annually for every 11,000 pools. By comparison, one child under 10 each year is killed by a gun for every 1 million guns, according to his research, outlined in a new book "Freakonomics: A Rogue Economist Explores the Hidden Side to Everything," which he co-wrote with journalist Stephen J. Dubner.
Someone should inform Jean Hanff Korelitz. She thinks that "more than 4,000 children...die in gun-related accidents each year". But let's check the numbers anyway. According to the CDC, in 2002 there were 676 drowning deaths for children up through 9 years of age. There were 26 accidental firearm deaths. There were 142 firearm deaths of all intents; accident, homicide, and suicide. According to the 2003 UN Small Arms Survey, there are an estimated 238 to 276 million firearms in the U.S. Wouldn't that mean somewhere between 238 and 275 "children under 10" dying by gunshot, not 142? Professor Levitt really ought to review his numbers more rigorously. It looks like the ratio is more like 175:1.

Shocking, no?

Still, the headline (above the fold!) was quite attention-grabbing.

P.S: My grandchildren are in mortal danger! I own (several) guns, and my wife and I are considering getting a pool!

Friday, June 10, 2005

Welcome, Joe Katzman.

Joe, a Canadian, has embraced the idea of the right to arms as a fundamental human right. Go read his Winds of Change essay on what changed his mind. Here's the opener:
As many of you know, I'm from Canada. We have a pretty different attitude to guns up here, and I must say that American gun culture has always kind of puzzled me. To me, one no more had a right to a gun than one did to a car.

Well, my mind has changed. Changed to the point where I see gun ownership as being a slightly qualified but universal global human right. A month ago in Yalta, Freedom & The Future, I wrote:

"Frankly, if "stopping... societies from becoming the homicidal hells Mr. Bush described in his Latvia speech" is our goal, I'm becoming more sympathetic to the Right to Bear Arms as a universal human right on par with freedom of speech and religion. U.S. Secretary of State Condi Rice's personal experience as a child in Birmingham [Alabama] adds an interesting dimension; I hope she talks about this abroad."

This week, I took the last step. You can thank Robert Mugabe, too, because it was his campaign to starve his political/tribal opponents and Pol-Pot style "ruralization" effort (200,000 left homeless recently in a population of 12.6 million) that finally convinced me. Here's the crux, the argument before which all other arguments pale into insignificance:

The Right to Bear Arms is the only reliable way to prevent genocide in the modern world.

And Zimbabwe is the poster child for that proposition.
Go read the whole thing.

And this would be a good time to re-read the Dangerous Victims trilogy. Oh, and most especially, Those Without Swords Can Still Die Upon Them.

Commerce Clause Satire.

(Title stolen from The Volokh Conspiracy - thanks to Mike of Feces Flinging Monkey for the email pointer.)

Fafblog! has taken a bit of umbrage at this week's Raich decision, and has decided to lampoon harpoon the decision with a little satire illustrating the mental gymnastics required to reach that decision. Good read, with graphics and everything, but here's the bit that got my gungeek attention:
Special Bonus Commerce PARADOX! A cat is in a box. According to quantum mechanics, it is neither bought nor sold. Instead it is a cat commerce waveform sold in all possible states at the same time until it is confiscated and destroyed by the Bureau of Alcohol Tobacco and Cats.
ZING!!!

Couldn't Happen to Nicer People, or "About Damned Time!"


I'd seen this news elsewhere, but Head of Head's Bunker has the best bit of news. It seems that the Folsom Gun Club in California has had enough of California's anti-gun antics and is striking back. They're officially banning California Department of Justice employees from using their range while acting in any official capacity.

Now that's good news. The great news? The Brady Bunch has their panties in a twist over it:
GUN ENTHUSIASTS GET UGLY IN CALIFORNIA LEGISLATIVE PUSH, LOCK STATE AGENTS OUT OF TRAINING FACILITY

Sacramento, CA – A shooting range here has announced a ban on use of its shooting facilities by employees of the California Department of Justice because the Department is supporting two bills in the State legislature that the club opposes.

The bills represent groundbreaking new ballistic identification systems which would give police new crime solving tools. Each would set up systems for markings on gun ammunition in California that would help law enforcement investigators track down the perpetrators of shootings that might otherwise remain unsolved. One bill (AB 352) would require handguns to include a device that stamps a specific number on bullets that are fired by that handgun, while the other (SB 357) would require that ammunition manufacturers mark ammunition with a serial number for potential tracking.

The bills have the support of the California DOJ. No California law enforcement organizations oppose the measures. In a letter to California Attorney General Bill Lockyer, Thomas S. Hause, President of the Folsom Shooting Club, which operates the Sacramento Valley Shooting Center outside Sacramento, wrote “The Board of Directors of the Folsom Shooting Club (FSC) has directed me to advise you, in writing, that Department of Justice staff, while acting in their official capacity, are suspended from using the Sacramento Valley Shooting Center (SVSC). The FSC is concerned that your staff will further your efforts regarding AB 352 and SB 357 while using our facility.”

Leaders of the Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence and the Million Mom March are urging the club to drop the policy immediately. “It is offensive that the owners of this shooting range would rather side with criminals than with law enforcement and victims, not to mention that they are discriminating against people simply because they have a different view on legislation,” said Amanda Wilcox, State Council Leader of the Million Mom March. “It is also very troubling when it is law enforcement agents who are using the facility for training purposes.”

“What’s next – should police who support sensible gun laws have their firearms taken away? This is un-American, and these guys ought to have their heads examined,” said Jim Brady, chair of the Brady Campaign.
"This is un-American!" I could make a comment about brain damage, but I won't.

But that's not the best part. No, indeed! I loved this:
The state Assembly has passed AB 352, which would give police the ability to match bullet shells at the scene of a crime to the gun that fired the bullet.
Wait! I thought that "ballistic fingerprinting" could do that already!

The two bills being pursued in the California legislature are right up there in terms of reality with repealing the law of gravity, or dictating to the car manufacturers that they WILL build zero-emissions vehicles that people will be willing to drive. And pay for.

But in La-la land they think that passing a law will magically make it so, and to hell with the facts.

It's about time that they saw some unintended consequences of their own. I applaud the Folsom Gun Club. I wonder if they need a new member?

Thursday, June 09, 2005

Dept. of One Line Movie Reviews that Should Win a Pulitzer


(Almost forgot this one.) Lileks today was in perfect form. He spent his entire Bleat column in a geekoid review of Star Wars: Revenge of the Sith, but he boils it all down in one, perfect line:
Genius. Pure genius.
To Defend Oneself....

Earlier this year I wrote a piece entitled Fear, The Philosophy and Politics Thereof. It was a pretty self-explanatory title, but in short the essay discussed the paranoia and, yes, revulsion that part of the population has against the idea of an armed citizenry. This is a topic I've covered before in the "violent-and-predatory" vs. "violent-but-protective" dichotomy illustrated in the Dangerous Victims trilogy.

In all of those pieces I described the problem as I saw it: an irrational fear of armed citizens - but I made no real effort to explain the why of that fear. For the purposes of those essays, illustrating that fear and showing its irrationality was enough.

But long-term it isn't enough. That fear is something I've been trying to grasp for some time. The first step in trying to bring someone over to your way of thinking is trying to understand their way of thinking. Then you can gently show them the really glaring logical flaws in their worldview and hopefully inspire an epiphany. (Thus one of the earliest posts here at TSM was Is the Government Responsible for Your Protection?) Of course, the further away they are from your position to start with the less likely your success, which is why I continually try to draw self-confessed "moderates" into debate. (Are you reading this, Alex?)

If you've been reading this blog long, you know that I recently finished LTC Dave Grossman's book On Killing: The Psychological Cost of Learning to Kill in War and Society. That book showed me some things that I hadn't previously considered. For example, in Section II, Chapter 5, The Winds of Hate, Grossman states:
All of us have had to face hostile aggression. On the playground as children, in the impoliteness of strangers, in the malicious gossip and comments of acquaintances, and in the animosity of peers and superiors in the workplace. In all of those instances everyone has known hostily and the stress it can cause. Most avoid confrontations at all costs and to work ourselves up to an aggressive verbal action - let alone a physical confrontation - is extremely difficult.

Simply confronting the boss about a promotion or a raise is one of the most stressful and upsetting things most people can ever bring themselves to do, and many never get that far. Facing down the school bully or confronting a hostile acquaintance is something that most will avoid at all costs.

--

The ultimate fear and horror in most modern lives is to be raped or beaten, to be physically degraded in front of our loved ones, to have our family harmed and the sanctity of our homes invaded by aggressive and hateful intruders. Death and debilitation by disease or accident are statistically far more likely to occur than death and debilitation by malicious action, but the statistics do not calm our basically irrational fears. It is not fear of death and injury from disease or accident but rather acts of personal depredation and domination by our fellow human beings that strike terror and loathing into our hearts.

--

The average citizen resists engaging in aggressive and assertive activities and dreads facing the irrational aggression and hatred of others. The soldier in combat is no different: he resists the powerful obligation and coercion to engage in aggresive and assertive actions on the battlefield, and he dreads facing the irrational aggression and hostility embodied in the enemy

Indeed, history is full of tales of soldiers who have committed suicide or inflicted terrible wounds upon themselves to avoid combat. It isn't fear of death that motivates these men to kill themselves. Like many of their civilian counterparts who commit suicide, these men would rather die or mutilate themselves than face the aggression and hostility of a very hostile world.
There's a lot to think about in that excerpt. Yes, physical confrontations are, for the majority, very difficult to "work yourself up to." Bullies tend to get what they want because most people would rather avoid than confront. Same for robbers. Yes, the greatest fear of most people is the fear of physical depredation, degradation, and domination at the hands of another. Is it "irrational" merely because the likelihood is low? I don't think so. It just is. How you handle that fear (or not) I think is what defines ones rationality. Killing yourself or self-inflicting grievous wounds is not, I think, a rational response. Neither is ignoring the risk altogether. But weighing the risks, and making a decision based on them is perfectly rational. (See Is the Gov't Responsible, Pt. II)

Further, because it is difficult to "work yourself up" to being aggressive, bullies and robbers, rapists and murderers are a (thankfully) pretty small portion of the population, thus making "death and debilitation by malicious action" a pretty rare thing. In the case of homicide, for instance, perpetrators usually have a long history of ever-increasing violent behavior before they finally "work themselves up to" murder.

Rare, yes, but not non-existant. Not by a long shot.

The thing that has bothered me the most in my study of history in general and the right to arms in particular is the tendency of societies to disarm themselves. I've had a hard time understanding that. As Robert Heinlein put it, "Roman matrons used to say to their sons: 'Come back with your shield, or on it.' Later on, this custom declined. So did Rome."

Want to talk about epiphanies? I had one a couple of days ago. Thanks to American Digest I found this quote by Alexander Solzhenitsyn from a speech he gave at Harvard in 1978:
In a state of psychological weakness, weapons become a burden for the capitulating side. To defend oneself, one must also be ready to die; there is little such readiness in a society raised in the cult of material well-being. Nothing is left, then, but concessions, attempts to gain time and betrayal.
Solzhenitsyn was speaking broadly about governments - Western governments particularly, but that statement I believe is equally applicable within the societies in question. It is true on the macro level because it is true on the micro level. Remember Tytler:
The average age of the world's greatest civilizations has been 200 years. These nations have progressed through the following sequence

From bondage to spiritual faith

From spiritual faith to great courage

From courage to liberty

From liberty to abundance

From abundance to selfishness

From selfishness to complacency

From complacency to apathy

From apathy to dependency

From dependency back again into bondage
Solzhenitsyn seems to agree with this progression, since "abundance" seems to lead to a "cult of material well-being," and apathy seems to meet his definition of "psychological weakness." Or perhaps it's dependency?

"The ultimate fear and horror" of the individual is "personal depredation and domination by our fellow human beings," yet the reaction of society is to encourage disarmament?

And they call us irrational?

To the "psychologically weak," anyone who is armed represents a threat of "personal depredation and domination" unless they believe that the possible predators are constrained by an outside force - in this case, government. That's why there is an acceptance of state-sanctioned use of violence where there is only rejection of the individual exercise of force. It's a coping mechanism. Solzhenitsyn is correct: to be willing to defend oneself, one must also be willing to risk ones death or debilitation at the hands of another, and "there is little such readiness in a society raised in the cult of material well-being." Such readiness is largely dependent on exposure to risk, and the "cult of material well-being" discourages such. Our very prosperity strips us of our willingness, if not our capacity, to resist. "No material thing is worth a human life" is a refrain we hear over and over again. Jeffery Snyder's A Nation of Cowards hammers on this point.
OUR SOCIETY has reached a pinnacle of self-expression and respect for individuality rare or unmatched in history. Our entire popular culture -- from fashion magazines to the cinema -- positively screams the matchless worth of the individual, and glories in eccentricity, nonconformity, independent judgment, and self-determination. This enthusiasm is reflected in the prevalent notion that helping someone entails increasing that person's "self-esteem"; that if a person properly values himself, he will naturally be a happy, productive, and, in some inexplicable fashion, responsible member of society.

And yet, while people are encouraged to revel in their individuality and incalculable self-worth, the media and the law enforcement establishment continually advise us that, when confronted with the threat of lethal violence, we should not resist, but simply give the attacker what he wants. If the crime under consideration is rape, there is some notable waffling on this point, and the discussion quickly moves to how the woman can change her behavior to minimize the risk of rape, and the various ridiculous, non-lethal weapons she may acceptably carry, such as whistles, keys, mace or, that weapon which really sends shivers down a rapist's spine, the portable cellular phone.

Now how can this be? How can a person who values himself so highly calmly accept the indignity of a criminal assault? How can one who believes that the essence of his dignity lies in his self-determination passively accept the forcible deprivation of that self-determination? How can he, quietly, with great dignity and poise, simply hand over the goods?

The assumption, of course, is that there is no inconsistency. The advice not to resist a criminal assault and simply hand over the goods is founded on the notion that one's life is of incalculable value, and that no amount of property is worth it. Put aside, for a moment, the outrageousness of the suggestion that a criminal who proffers lethal violence should be treated as if he has instituted a new social contract: "I will not hurt or kill you if you give me what I want." For years, feminists have labored to educate people that rape is not about sex, but about domination, degradation, and control. Evidently, someone needs to inform the law enforcement establishment and the media that kidnapping, robbery, carjacking, and assault are not about property.

Crime is not only a complete disavowal of the social contract, but also a commandeering of the victim's person and liberty. If the individual's dignity lies in the fact that he is a moral agent engaging in actions of his own will, in free exchange with others, then crime always violates the victim's dignity. It is, in fact, an act of enslavement. Your wallet, your purse, or your car may not be worth your life, but your dignity is; and if it is not worth fighting for, it can hardly be said to exist.
But until I read Solzhenitsyn's words, it never really clicked for me. I saw it, I accepted the fact of it, but I didn't really understand it. Denise at The Ten Ring did a two-part post last week on "Types of Anti-Gunnies," which she broke down into "True Hoplophobes," "Pacifists," "Legal-Eagles," "Victims," "Opportunists," "Elitists," and "Statists." I think that she's largely correct in her categorizations (bearing in mind that there might be significant overlap of definition for any particular individual in question), but the characteristic "psychological weakness" described by Solzhenitsyn is primarily manifested in the Hoplophobes, Pacifists, and Victims. These are then used by the Legal-Eagles, Opportunitsts, Elitists and Statists, but each and every one of them to some has either not considered the risks, or rejected those risks not only for themselves, but for everyone else.
Quote of the Day.

Edward O. Wilson, the world's foremost expert on ants, remarking about Marxism: "Wonderful theory. Wrong species."

Amen.

(Found in Janice Rogers Brown's speech "A Whiter Shade of Pale.") GREAT speech.

PreCISELY!


I was listening to Hugh Hewitt's radio show on the way home yesterday. On Wednesday afternoons he has "The Smart Guys" on, Erwin Chemerinsky (from the left), law professor at USC, and John Eastman (from the right), law professor at Chapman University. Well, yesterday Hugh was asking them both about their opinions of the appointment of Janice Rogers Brown. Hugh's producer Duane Patterson runs the blog Radioblogger and has the transcript. Chemerinsky whined about how "out of the mainstream" Brown was:
I think it's sad. I think Janice Rogers Brown is pretty much as far to the right on the political spectrum as you're going to get for a federal Court of Appeals. She said that she believes the social security program is unconstitutional.
That's just a set-up for what's coming, though, because a few minutes later we got this exchange:
John Eastman: You know, I mean, it's just so preposterous, I don't even know where to begin. The reason Chuck Schumer is so upset about this, is Justice Brown is the kind of judge who will, you know, adhere to the Constitution. And when the members of the legislature, even the exalted Chuck Schumer hismelf, want to take actions that is not authorized by the Constitution, she'll be willing to stand up and do her duty, and strike it down. That's not an arrogance, that's what the judges are there for, to adhere to the Constitution, and not to let the legislature roll over them and do whatever they want. You know, it really is preposterous. We've turned this upside down. The judges that do exactly what they're supposed to do are demonized, and those that take a powder and let the legislature get away with every abuse, every extension of power imaginable, are touted at the cocktail circuit.

Erwin Chemerinsky: I think what Senator Schumer is saying, and is absolutely right, is that Janice Rogers Brown's repeated statements that she believes that the New Deal programs like social security are unconstitutional, is truly a radical view. That's not a judge who wants to uphold the Constitution. That's a judge who wants to shred the last eighty years of American Constitutional law. Janice Rogers Brown saying she believes that the Bill of Rights should not apply to the states, would undo the last seventy years of Constitutional law. That's not a judge who wants to follow the law. That's a judge who wants to make the law in her own radical, conservative views.

John Eastman: Hang on, here, because Erwin...there's a wonderfully subtle change in your phraseology that demonstrates what's going on here. You said she won't follow the Constitution, and then you said it's because she won't follow the last seventy or eighty years of Constitutional law. What happened seventy or eighty years ago that changed the Constitution? There was not a single amendment at issue in the 1930's that changed the Constitution. Some radical, federal programs were pushed through. Some radical judges, under pressure, finally signed on them, and the notion that we can't question that unconstitutional action that occurred in the 1930's, and somehow that defending that unconstitutionality is adherent to the rule of law, is rather extraordinary. There are scholars on left and right that have understood that what went on in the 1930's was...had no basis in Constitutional law, or in the letter of the Constitution itself.
THANK you, John Eastman for smacking down Chemerinsky when he so richly deserved it. Game, set, match.

And thanks to Duane Patterson for transcribing that spanking. (There's quite a bit more, if you're interested.) It made my day!

Wednesday, June 08, 2005

I Think He Slipped the Hook, Dammit.

Remember last month's Banana Oil! post A Challenge? (Ian's bandwidth has been slammed by Google image searchers, so his site is not available right now.) I thought I'd hooked a self-defined gun-control "moderate" into a discussion on the right to arms. That was May 24, two full weeks ago. As of yet, he hasn't responded to the invitation to join TSM for our debate, and I'm losing hope that he's going to.

Damn. I was so looking forward to it.

UPDATE: Alex assures me he will post, and has a four-page opener just needing some editing before doing so. Please stand by.

Quote of the Week: Janice Rogers Brown.

But first, please peruse this post from Gunner at No Quarters, and study that last picture very closely.

Anyway, on to the quote:
I have argued that collectivism was (and is) fundamentally incompatible with the vision that undergirded this country’s founding. The New Deal, however, inoculated the federal Constitution with a kind of underground collectivist mentality. The Constitution itself was transmuted into a significantly different document...1937...marks the triumph of our own socialist revolution...Politically, the belief in human perfectibility is another way of asserting that differences between the few and the many can, over time, be erased. That creed is a critical philosophical proposition underlying the New Deal. What is extraordinary is the way that thesis infiltrated and effected American constitutionalism over the next three-quarters of a century. Its effect was not simply to repudiate, both philosophically and in legal doctrine, the framers’ conception of humanity, but to cut away the very ground on which the Constitution rests... In the New Deal/Great Society era, a rule that was the polar opposite of the classical era of American law reigned.
Man, would I like to have the unabridged text of that speech! There's lots more over at the People for the (un)American Way site. I figure they parsed her quotes to make them as "damning" as they could, but I have to admit I liked them all.

More on Ms. Brown tomorrow, I hope.

Three Strikes and You're Out, Or Third Time's the Charm?


In either case, please note which direction they're travelling every time.

Back in February of last year I posted Love that Detroit Iron! which I will repost here in its entirety:
You have to give them an "A" for effort, or at least persistence. What a way to reimport the classics!

Marciel Basanta Lopez and Luis Gras Rodriguez have again attempted to sail from Cuba to Florida, but once again have unfortunately been intercepted by the Coast Guard short of their goal. Back in July they made the journey in a specially modified 1951 Chevy pickup.

Yes, really. Here's a picture of it:


Well, they just nabbed them (and eight of their friends and relatives) trying again. This time in a specially modified 1959 Buick!
They must have a lot of that funky green paint.

What's next? A 1955 Ford?
Well, they must've run out of green paint, and instead of a '55 Ford, they used a '48 Mercury:
Migrants' 'taxicab' boat stopped at sea

The Coast Guard halted a homemade craft about 25 miles off the Keys that looked like a taxi. The boat was loaded with Cuban migrants.

BY JENNIFER BABSON
jbabson@herald.com


KEY WEST - A blue, 1948 Mercury automobile loaded with Cuban migrants made it within 25 miles of the Keys late Tuesday before being stopped by the U.S. Coast Guard.

The unusual, homemade 'boat' -- described by federal officials as possibly a 'taxicab' and sporting a white top -- was stopped south of Summerland Key in the Lower Keys. It was the third time in nearly two years that Cuban migrants have tried to make it to the United States using trucks or cars specially rigged to operate as boats.

One of the men aboard the Mercury tried to make the voyage in February 2004 in a Buick but was sent back to Cuba, according to Luis Grass -- the brainchild behind similar attempts who made his way to Miami this year.
I wonder what Luis "drove" on his successful attempt?
BOARDING THE CRAFT

Television footage from NBC 6 in Miami on Tuesday night showed Coast Guard officers boarding the vehicle, which appeared to have been modified with a boat prow in front.

As many as 12 Cubans voluntarily left the car late Tuesday and moved onto a Coast Guard cutter, according to numerous federal sources. It was not immediately known if they would be returned to Cuba.

The interdiction unfolded just before dusk Tuesday.

"A U.S. Customs and Border Protection aircraft detected it just before 8 p.m.," said customs spokesman Zachary Mann. "According to our guys, it looked like a floating taxi."

Citing U.S. policy, Coast Guard spokeswoman Sandra Bartlett said she could not immediately comment on the incident or whether the migrants would be returned to Cuba, a process that could take several days.

Under the U.S. wet-foot, dry-foot immigration policy, Cubans who reach U.S. soil are almost always allowed to remain in the country, while those caught offshore are generally returned to Cuba unless they can convince a U.S. immigration officer they have a 'credible fear' of persecution if returned to the island.

'DRIVING' THE WAY

It was the latest in a series of recent attempts by Cubans to try to 'drive' their way to the Keys.

In July 2003, a group of Cuban migrants -- dubbed "truckonauts" and heralded for their ingenuity -- attempted to flee Cuba in a retrofitted, green 1951 Chevy truck. The group was stopped off Islamorada -- their truck-boat floating on a pontoon bed and powered by propellers that had been attached to the vehicle's drive shaft.

The vessel was sunk at sea as a hazard to navigation.

Returned to Cuba, several of the Cubans tried again in February 2004 using a similarly rigged 1959 Buick sedan. At least some of those who attempted that voyage, however, were taken to Guantánamo Bay in Cuba for resettlement in a third country.

Among that group was Grass, an enterprising mechanic credited with converting the classic vehicles into seaworthy escape vessels. Grass, his wife and young son were among 20 Cuban migrants resettled in Costa Rica last November.

ANOTHER TRY

Grass said late Tuesday that one of his pals -- who may have subsequently received a U.S. visa after failing last year to reach Florida by Buick -- made Tuesday's voyage with his two sons and his wife, who was having difficulty leaving Cuba because she is a doctor.

"He finally made a taxi from Havana to Miami," chuckled Grass, who told The Herald he spoke with the man's friends in Havana late Tuesday.

The group, he said, was from San Miguel Del Padron in Havana.

Grass and his family finally made it to the United States in March after crossing the Mexican border and requesting political asylum.
You have to admire their ingenuity and doggedness.

Behind the Curve

Kim, Kim, Kim...

I know you've been busy, but I take time to read YOUR site every day.... ;-)

I covered the story of UK teacher Linda Walker back in April. Turns out that she's been released already, but she's not a happy camper:
I felt I was being crucified by the full force of the law, says teacher jailed for waving air pistol at yobs

By David Harrison
(Filed: 08/05/2005)


A special needs teacher jailed for defending her home against a gang of thugs said last night that she felt as if she had been "crucified" by the system.
That's because she'd been crucified by the system.
Linda Walker, a middle-class mother-of-three described her time in prison as "humiliating". She was strip-searched, put on suicide watch, forced to go on hunger strike and suffered panic attacks during which she thought she would die.

Mrs Walker, 48, was jailed for brandishing an unloaded air pistol in front of a gang of thugs she believed had terrorised her family for two years while the police did nothing. Her sentence provoked outrage and her case became a symbol of Britain's law-and-order crisis.

Mrs Walker was released by the Court of Appeal last Wednesday after the judges said she should not have been jailed in the first place.
But she was. And that jailing was covered pretty heavily.

The result of which is another reminder to the populace not to "take the law into their own hands." Another "chilling effect" that keeps the sheep in their place.
Last night, back at her home in a Manchester suburb after spending 38 nights in jail alongside drug addicts, she spoke for the first time of her ordeal and how she felt let down by the criminal justice system.
Her and thousands of others.
Speaking to the Mail on Sunday, she said: "I've spent my life supporting the weakest and most vulnerable members of the community. But when I needed support from the establishment, not only was it not there, but the full force of the of the law came down on me like a ton of bricks. I felt like I was being crucified."
The nail that sticks up gets hammered down, goes the old Japanese proverb.
Her worst moment came two weeks into her sentence when she was told that her application to be released on bail had been refused. She felt there had been a conspiracy, that she was "an embarrassment to the Government" and that she was a "political prisoner", kept in jail "because I raised embarrassing and sensitive issues just before a general election".
I think that's getting to be the equivalent of a felony there. Don't embarrass those in power.

Come to think of it, it's getting to be a felony here.
"The issues were anti-social behaviour, gun crime, householders' rights and why there are so many women in prison.

"I felt so trapped, but I wasn't going to be swept under the mat. I told the prison governor I had kept quiet about my case but I had plenty I wanted to say."

Mrs Walker went on hunger strike for three days. She had a heart attack and thought she was going to die.

"It was two or three in the morning," she said. "I felt totally alone. The place was frightening and intimidating and feelings of helplessness overcame me. I'd had a panic attack during the day which caused my heart to pound at a frightening rate. I had never had one before.

"As I lay awake, it began to beat hard and fast again and I became desperately worried.

"My grandmother died of a heart attack after losing weight quickly. I had lost weight as a result of my hunger strike and I know that the heart is a muscle and if you lose weight too quickly, it can be seriously weakened.

"Alone in my cell, I became very frightened that I might die and never see my family again. I also felt petrified because I had no control over my own destiny and I felt people were conspiring against me."

Mrs Walker was found guilty of affray and possessing a firearm with intent to cause fear of violence. She was sentenced to six months imprisonment by a Manchester court on March 29.
Meanwhile, the "yobs" who tormented her and her family are still out, free, and running around.
She felt, she said, "more like a naughty child than a criminal". After all, her crime was simply to confront a gang who for two years had made her family's life a misery through spiteful acts of vandalism.

Her shed had been broken into and bicycles stolen; garden ornaments had been dumped into her pond; there had been threatening telephone calls and petty acts of sabotage.

Goaded beyond endurance, she had fired an unloaded, gas-powered airgun into the pavement near the toes of the gang leader. Supporting her in court were her partner John Cavanagh, 57, her daughter Donna, 20, and her father Jim Mairs, 78, an ex-Royal Marine. Mrs Walker said: "I didn't take anything to court. I was not prepared for prison - not even a toothbrush.

"I was confident the pre-sentencing reports the judge had requested would keep me out of jail because it stated in one that prison would be 'highly inappropriate'."

When she was moved to Styal prison, near Manchester airport, the inmates treated her like a heroine. "Well done Linda!" they shouted. "You should have bazooka'd them."
Note that even the imprisoned think that fighting back is a good idea.
She was deluged with more than 2,000 cards and letters of support, including one from Tony Martin, the farmer jailed for killing a teenage burglar, and many from her pupils.

Mrs Walker said she would never forget her ordeal. "Some people lose everything when they go to prison. My experiences will live with me for ever. But I'm fortunate because I still have my home and my family."
I don't think they'd have let her out except for fear that she'd die in prison and become a martyr. Can't have that. And if they could have figured out a way to confiscate her property, I'm not too sure they wouldn't have done that.

I don't hold out much any hope for the UK any more. They're going to have to bottom out first. There's no chance to arrest their descent any more.

Monday, June 06, 2005

Et Tu, Nino?


It appears that even Antonin Scalia has feet of clay.

By now everyone has heard that the Supreme Court has decided Raich v. Gonzales in favor of the power of the Federal government, and Scalia was one of the 6-3 majority.

Quite honestly, I'm saddened. It's not that I didn't expect the decision to turn out that way, but that Scalia upheld it...

I'm surprised.

That he upheld it at least partially under the precedent of Wickard v. Filburn? That's angering.

For those of you not steeped in historical jurisprudence, Wickard v. Filburn was a New Deal-era Supreme Court decision that essentially granted limitless powers of regulation to the federal government. At issue was the Agricultural Adjustment Act of 1938, which regulated wheat production under the Commerce Clause of the Constitution. A farmer in Ohio, Filburn, grew wheat on his farm for the explicit purpose of feeding his livestock and himself. It was not grown for sale, either intrastate or interstate. The Agricultural Adjustment Act limited the acreage a farmer could plant for sale so as to help control the wheat market. Farmer Filburn was allotted 11.1 acres. He grew about 23 acres. The court found against him, the argument (in part) being that what he grew for his own consumption affected interstate commerce.

It seems a simple thing, but the point of the matter is whether the contract that is the Constitution means what it says. I don't think you could argue that the Founders meant for the Federal government to have the power to dictate to farmers what they could or could not grow for their own use, but that's what the Wickard decision said it meant. And that decision pretty much opened the door for the federal government to regulate everything - for what doesn't "affect" interstate commerce? This was a massive expansion in federal powers, one of several that occurred during FDR's presidency.

But back to Scalia.

I've quoted before from a speech he gave on March 14 of this year, and I'm going to do it again. Justice Scalia makes a lot of his being an "originalist," a "textualist" in his interpretation of the Constitution. Here he illustrates that even the general public, once upon a time, was too:
Consider the 19th Amendment, which is the amendment that gave women the vote. It was adopted by the American people in 1920. Why did we adopt a constitutional amendment for that purpose? The Equal Protection Clause existed in 1920; it was adopted right after the Civil War. And you know that if the issue of the franchise for women came up today, we would not have to have a constitutional amendment. Someone would come to the Supreme Court and say, “Your Honors, in a democracy, what could be a greater denial of equal protection than denial of the franchise?” And the Court would say, “Yes! Even though it never meant it before, the Equal Protection Clause means that women have to have the vote.” But that’s not how the American people thought in 1920. In 1920, they looked at the Equal Protection Clause and said, “What does it mean?” Well, it clearly doesn’t mean that you can’t discriminate in the franchise — not only on the basis of sex, but on the basis of property ownership, on the basis of literacy. None of that is unconstitutional. And therefore, since it wasn’t unconstitutional, and we wanted it to be, we did things the good old fashioned way and adopted an amendment.
Or to paraphrase: “Yes! Even though it never meant it before, the Commerce Clause means that the federal government can control what farmers grow for their own consumption.” Or what sick people grow for theirs.

Now, I find it fascinating that at about the same time that we passed the 19th Amendment we also passed another, the 18th, which outlawed "intoxicating liquors." Funny, though, that we didn't have to pass an amendment to outlaw other intoxicating substances. No, in 1914 Congress passed the Harrison Narcotic Act instead, beginning a nearly century-long "War on (some) Drugs™" with all attendant unintended consequences. And the federal government using Wickard v. Filburn and other decisions has expanded its power exponentially trying to enforce the Harrison Act and its offspring.*

Now, granted, Scalia more strongly relies on the Necessary and Proper clause in his concurrance, but that's just icing on the cake as far as I'm concerned. Radley Balko has the right of it in proclaiming of Justice Clarence Thomas's dissent the only opinion that was "dead on":
Thomas was dead-on, and proves to be the only principled federalist with an orginalist view of the Commerce Clause.
If Congress can regulate this under the Commerce Clause, then it can regulate virtually anything--and the Federal Government is no longer one of limited and enumerated powers.

[...]

Certainly no evidence from the founding suggests that "commerce" included the mere possession of a good or some purely personal activity that did not involve trade or exchange for value. In the early days of the Republic, it would have been unthinkable that Congress could prohibit the local cultivation, possession, and consumption of marijuana.
And he notes that Thomas specifically disagrees with Scalia's use of the Necessary and Proper clause:
In Lopez, I argued that allowing Congress to regulate intrastate, noncommercial activity under the Commerce Clause would confer on Congress a general "police power" over the Nation. This is no less the case if Congress ties its power to the Necessary and Proper Clause rather than the Commerce Clause. When agents from the Drug Enforcement Administration raided Monson's home, they seized six cannabis plants. If the Federal Government can regulate growing a half-dozen cannabis plants for personal consumption (not because it is interstate commerce, but because it is inextricably bound up with interstate commerce), then Congress' Article I powers--as expanded by the Necessary and Proper Clause--have no meaningful limits. Whether Congress aims at the possession of drugs, guns, or any number of other items, it may continue to appropria[te] state police powers under the guise of "regulating commerce."
And this is what Scalia protests against - the federal government having no meaningful limits on its power. Scalia said in another speech
The only reason you need a constitution is because some things you don't want the majority to be able to change. That's my most important function as a judge in this system. I have to tell the majority to take a hike.
He missed a chance today. Thomas didn't.

*(And if you want to know my position on the War on (some) Drugs™, please read It is Not the Business of Government)

UPDATE, 6/7: The Geek with a .45, commenting on the Raich decision said this:
It seems. Prof. Tribe was quite right to suspend work on his second volume.
Perhaps so.